Can Vision Regress After SMILE Pro?

Prepared by: Editorial Team

Short answer

Vision correction after SMILE Pro stays stable in most people, but in some eyes the prescription can partly return or a small residual error can remain. The likelihood depends on age, the size of the prescription and eye structure. If needed, enhancement options such as surface ablation or thin-flap LASIK are discussed with your doctor.

Vision correction after SMILE Pro stays stable in most people, but in some eyes the prescription can partly return, or a small residual error can remain right after surgery. The factors that influence this vary from person to person, and no surgeon can predict it with certainty in advance. This article explains what it means when vision regresses, why it can happen and what enhancement options exist.

Are regression and residual error the same thing?

People often confuse the two. A residual error is a correction that does not quite reach its target right after surgery, called undercorrection or overcorrection. Regression is a good initial correction that partly fades over time. A review of retreatment options notes that a leftover refractive error after SMILE can result from regression, overcorrection, undercorrection or newly induced astigmatism (PMID 30368350). Only an examination and repeated measurements can show which of these applies.

Is the result of SMILE Pro expected to stay stable?

A review of long-term outcomes reports that SMILE shows excellent stability, especially in higher myopia (PMID 29283117). The same review notes that visual and refractive results have improved as the technique has advanced. Stability is still not a guarantee. A laser procedure also does not prevent changes that may develop in the eye later. Age-related near-vision difficulty (presbyopia) and conditions such as cataract can affect vision again regardless of the surgery. A feeling that "my prescription is back" is therefore not always about the durability of the operation itself.

What can increase the chance of regression?

The factors are individual. In general, doctors consider the following:

  • Whether your prescription was stable before surgery; young eyes whose prescription is still changing may carry a higher risk.
  • The size of the corrected prescription.
  • The presence and amount of astigmatism; concerns about the precision of astigmatism correction have been discussed in the literature (PMID 31490198).
  • The state of the ocular surface during healing and how regularly the drops are used.
  • Individual differences in eye structure, such as continued lengthening of the eye.

For this reason your prescription history is reviewed in detail before surgery. See SMILE Pro pre-operative exam and preparation for more about that process.

What enhancement options exist if more correction is needed?

A leftover or returning prescription can be treated with an enhancement. According to the reviews, unlike LASIK, repeating SMILE itself is currently not approved and is performed only rarely. Instead, these main options are used (PMID 31513041, PMID 30368350):

  • Surface ablation: this keeps the flap-free approach, but pain and slower visual recovery make it less attractive for some patients.
  • Cap-to-flap conversion with the CIRCLE program: a femtosecond laser converts the SMILE cap into a LASIK flap; recovery is quick, but a flap has to be created.
  • Thin-flap LASIK: recovery is quick, but it also requires creating a flap.
  • Secondary SMILE: a method discussed for selected situations.

The reviews report that these options have safety and efficacy comparable to LASIK retreatments, with patient-specific advantages and disadvantages. The suitable method depends on the earlier SMILE parameters, especially cap thickness, and on corneal structure (PMID 31513041).

What should you do if you notice a change in your vision?

Do not make a decision right away. Temporary causes such as dry eye, screen fatigue or an unrelated eye condition should be ruled out first. Your doctor will examine you and repeat topography and other measurements if needed. For normal fluctuations during healing, see recovery after SMILE Pro. If you have sudden vision loss, a curtain over your vision or severe pain, see an eye doctor without waiting.

Attending follow-up visits matters here, because small changes in prescription can be picked up by measurements before symptoms begin. Before an additional procedure is decided, doctors make sure the prescription has stayed the same over several measurements, since fluctuations during healing may not be lasting regression.

A similar discussion of residual error and regression applies to excimer laser methods, covered in can prescription return after laser surgery. To learn which prescriptions SMILE Pro can treat, read which prescriptions can SMILE Pro correct.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can SMILE be repeated if the prescription returns?

According to the reviews, repeating it with the same method is currently not approved and is rarely done. Options such as surface ablation, cap-to-flap conversion with CIRCLE or thin-flap LASIK are used instead.

Is enhancement possible for everyone?

No. Corneal thickness, the parameters of the earlier procedure and eye health determine suitability. Your doctor will discuss the right option after an examination.

Does a returning prescription mean the surgery was wasted?

No. Even when a small prescription appears, most people still need much less correction than before surgery. It is nevertheless important to know that results vary from person to person.

What can I do to lower the chance of regression?

Do not skip your drops or follow-up visits, avoid rubbing your eyes and make sure your prescription was stable before surgery. These steps may help reduce the risk, but they cannot remove it.

Scientific references

  1. Moshirfar M, Shah TJ, Masud M, et al.. Surgical options for retreatment after small-incision lenticule extraction: Advantages and disadvantages. J Cataract Refract Surg. 2018. PMID: 30368350
  2. Siedlecki J, Luft N, Priglinger SG, et al.. Enhancement Options After Myopic Small-Incision Lenticule Extraction (SMILE): A Review. Asia Pac J Ophthalmol (Phila). 2019. PMID: 31513041
  3. Ganesh S, Brar S, Arra RR. Refractive lenticule extraction small incision lenticule extraction: A new refractive surgery paradigm. Indian J Ophthalmol. 2018. PMID: 29283117
Treatment pageSMILE Pro Laser Eye Surgery in DenizliDetailed information on the SMILE Pro method, who can be considered, the process and risks.

The information on this site is not a substitute for consulting a doctor or pharmacist. The information, comments and images on the site are for informational purposes and are not intended to direct people to diagnosis and treatment. All the surgical procedures described on our website are performed in a hospital environment.

Online Appointment

Editorial team

Contact the Editor

Have a question, a correction or a comment about this article? Send a message to our editorial team.

Regarding: Can Vision Regress After SMILE Pro?

Your details are used only to reply to your message.

Last updated: