Who Should Avoid Multifocal (Smart) Lenses?

Prepared by: Editorial Team

Short answer

A multifocal (smart) lens may not be suitable with retinal disease, regular astigmatism above 1 dioptre, zonular weakness or pseudoexfoliation. Eyes with glaucoma or diabetes need individual assessment. Suitability is decided after a detailed examination, including tests such as OCT, and it differs from person to person.

A multifocal (smart) lens is not suitable for every eye; retinal disease, certain corneal and lens-support problems, and some other eye conditions can limit the choice. Suitability depends on a detailed examination of your eye, not on your age alone. Below we explain which conditions need care and why.

How many candidates turn out to be suitable?

In a screening study at a public hospital, 1200 consecutive patients were evaluated before surgery. Of these, 768 were included for bilateral surgery, and 346 (45.1%) were considered suitable candidates for a multifocal lens. The remaining 422 (54.9%) were excluded because of one or both eyes. Among those excluded, 28.7% had retinal disease, 28.4% had regular astigmatism above 1.0 dioptre, and 7.5% had pseudoexfoliation or zonular instability. These figures come from a single centre and its specific exclusion criteria, so they may not apply to you. They do show that suitability should not be taken for granted.

Can a multifocal lens be used with retinal disease?

Retinal disease is regarded as a relative contraindication for multifocal lenses, because it can affect how the lens performs. In a survey of 111 Korean retinal specialists, the specialists disapproved of implanting a multifocal lens in these situations:

  • Wet age-related macular degeneration.
  • Dry age-related macular degeneration with geographic atrophy.
  • Proliferative diabetic retinopathy.
  • Non-proliferative diabetic retinopathy with macular oedema.
  • A previous macula-off retinal detachment, a previous retinal vein occlusion, or an epiretinal membrane.

The level of approval varied with the type and severity of the condition. These results reflect expert opinion rather than a fixed rule.

What about people with diabetes?

Multifocal lenses are often discouraged in people with, or at risk of, retinal disorders such as diabetic retinopathy and age-related macular degeneration, because they are thought to reduce contrast sensitivity. One review found conflicting results: some studies showed no effect, while others showed worse performance in low light and at higher spatial frequencies. Concurrent diabetic retinopathy is also listed among the factors that raise the risk of serious complications from cataract surgery. See premium lenses in diabetic patients for more.

Can a smart lens be used in glaucoma?

A systematic review of premium lenses in glaucoma evaluated 12 studies and reported high spectacle independence for distance vision and good patient satisfaction. Even so, the choice must take into account the glaucoma subtype, the type and severity of visual field defects, ocular surface disease, changes after glaucoma surgery and how reliably the disease can be monitored. Evidence on the effect on visual field testing is limited: no study has looked at glaucoma patients implanted with an EDOF or multifocal lens. Decisions in glaucoma are therefore made with particular care. See also cataract and glaucoma together.

What other conditions can cause problems?

Factors linked with poorer vision quality after multifocal lenses include older age, abnormal OCT findings and abnormal optical axis measurements. Higher regular astigmatism needs to be addressed first, and ocular surface problems such as dry eye can distort measurements. Our article on whether dry eye affects measurements before a smart lens may help. Previous laser surgery, nervous system problems and eye movement disorders are also considered during assessment.

What if I am not suitable?

Being unsuitable for a multifocal lens does not mean a lens cannot be implanted; it only means another lens type is more appropriate. Not being suitable does not mean you will not see well. A monofocal lens, with glasses when needed, can be a safe and effective option. If you have astigmatism, a toric lens is assessed separately. For a comparison, see monofocal or premium intraocular lens. If you have sudden vision loss, severe pain or a sensation of a curtain falling across your sight, see an eye doctor without delay.

Why is the suitability decision individual?

Even among people with retinal disease, results are not the same. In a review, two studies of patients who had a concurrent retinal disease and received a multifocal lens reported a significant improvement in vision-related outcomes. This shows that retinal disease is not always an absolute barrier, but that the type and severity of the disease are decisive. In people with diabetes, the likelihood of developing diabetic retinopathy rises with a longer duration of diabetes and with higher blood sugar and blood pressure. Diabetes control and the state of the macula are therefore assessed before surgery. Factors before, during and after the operation all matter for managing complications and improving the visual result.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can everyone with a healthy retina have a multifocal lens?

No. Even with a healthy retina, astigmatism, zonular support, the ocular surface and other measurements determine suitability.

Is a smart lens completely ruled out if I have glaucoma?

It cannot be generalized this way. Some studies have reported good results, but the decision is individual and depends on the type and severity of the disease.

I have diabetes but my retina is clear. Am I suitable?

This depends on your retinal and macular examination and OCT results. The duration of diabetes and blood sugar control also matter.

How is suitability decided?

A detailed eye examination, biometry, corneal measurements and retinal imaging are assessed together. The outcome differs from person to person.

Scientific references

  1. Halkiadakis I, Ntravalias T, Kollia E, et al.. Screening for multifocal intraocular lens implantation in cataract patients in a public hospital. Int Ophthalmol. 2024. PMID: 38507136
  2. Lee JH, Kong M, Sohn JH, et al.. Analysis of Korean Retinal Specialists' Opinions on Implanting Diffractive Multifocal Intraocular Lenses in Eyes with Underlying Retinal Diseases. J Clin Med. 2022. PMID: 35407444
  3. Hong ASY, Ang BCH, Dorairaj E, et al.. Premium Intraocular Lenses in Glaucoma-A Systematic Review. Bioengineering (Basel). 2023. PMID: 37760095
  4. Grzybowski A, Kanclerz P, Tuuminen R. Multifocal intraocular lenses and retinal diseases. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol. 2020. PMID: 31955239
Treatment pageCataract Surgery with Smart Lenses in DenizliDetailed information on trifocal and EDOF lenses, suitability assessment, measurements, the process and risks.

The information on this site is not a substitute for consulting a doctor or pharmacist. The information, comments and images on the site are for informational purposes and are not intended to direct people to diagnosis and treatment. All the surgical procedures described on our website are performed in a hospital environment.

Online Appointment

Editorial team

Contact the Editor

Have a question, a correction or a comment about this article? Send a message to our editorial team.

Regarding: Who Should Avoid Multifocal (Smart) Lenses?

Your details are used only to reply to your message.

Last updated: