Short answer
Every corneal laser procedure removes tissue, so some loss of corneal strength occurs with each method. Meta-analyses suggest that biomechanical measurements may be better after SMILE than after LASIK, but how this translates into long-term clinical outcomes is uncertain. The deciding factor is a detailed assessment of the cornea before surgery.
Because tissue is removed in corneal laser surgery, corneal strength decreases to some extent with every method. Meta-analyses comparing SMILE with LASIK report that biomechanical values measured after SMILE may be better than after LASIK. However, what this difference means for patients in the long term is not yet settled. This article explains what corneal strength is, how the two procedures compare and where the evidence has limits.
What does corneal strength (biomechanics) mean?
The cornea is the clear, dome-shaped tissue at the front of the eye. Its ability to hold its shape and focusing power depends on the strength of its layered collagen structure. Biomechanics describes how this tissue responds to pressure, including the pressure inside the eye. When tissue is removed during laser treatment, the cornea can weaken. A rare but serious result is progressive thinning and forward bulging of the cornea, called ectasia, which impairs vision.
How do SMILE and LASIK affect the cornea differently?
In LASIK, a flap is created on the corneal surface, lifted, and an excimer laser treats the tissue underneath. In SMILE, a femtosecond laser creates a piece of tissue inside the cornea, which is removed through a small incision; there is no flap. This difference preserves much of the front layers of the cornea. One review listed greater tectonic strength among the possible advantages of SMILE (PMID 31106754). For background on the methods, see what are LASIK and FemtoLASIK and the difference between SMILE and SMILE Pro.
What do comparison studies show?
A systematic review and meta-analysis comparing the biomechanics of SMILE with other corneal laser methods included 22 studies. Biomechanical measures after SMILE were better than after femtosecond LASIK and LASIK, and similar to femtosecond lenticule extraction (FLEX) (PMID 31370817). Compared with surface ablation methods (PRK and LASEK), no advantage for SMILE was shown. However, the results varied considerably between studies, and the measurements rely on laboratory instruments.
In a randomized paired-eye study, SMILE and femtosecond LASIK were similar for visual acuity and dry eye measurements, while the back surface of the cornea showed a greater backward shift over time in SMILE eyes (PMID 39591576). This does not mean that SMILE is better on every biomechanical measure; the study was small and its clinical meaning is still unclear.
What are the limits of the evidence?
Several points deserve attention:
- Biomechanical measurements reflect true corneal strength only indirectly; a measured difference is not always a clinical difference.
- A review explicitly states that the possible advantages of SMILE in biomechanical stability, inflammation and dry eye have not been fully established (PMID 25804585).
- SMILE and LASIK give similar results for visual acuity and predictability, and the choice is made according to individual findings (PMID 38700941).
- Recent evidence-based guidelines emphasize careful patient selection for lenticule extraction surgery (PMID 39577672).
A claim such as "this method fully protects the cornea" is therefore not supported by the science. When you talk to your doctor, it is more useful to focus on your own corneal measurements and the amount of tissue that will remain than on the name of the method. With either method, the aim is to leave enough healthy tissue after treatment.
Which assessments lower the risk of ectasia?
With either method, safety depends on a detailed examination of the cornea before surgery. The assessment looks at:
- Corneal topography and tomography, including signs of keratoconus and early or hidden keratoconus.
- Corneal thickness and the amount of tissue that will remain after treatment.
- The size of the prescription, because a higher prescription means more tissue is removed.
- Family history of keratoconus and any habit of eye rubbing.
These tests are described in corneal tests before laser eye surgery. You can read how at-risk corneas are identified in hidden keratoconus and laser surgery. For general suitability, see who is suitable for SMILE Pro.
When deciding on surgery, it is not only today's visual goal that is considered but also the health of the cornea in the years ahead. Your age, whether your prescription is stable and any family history of eye disease are therefore reviewed with your doctor.
When should you see a doctor?
If, months or years after surgery, you notice gradually worsening blurriness, a rapidly changing prescription or double or ghost images, see an eye doctor. Sudden vision loss, severe pain or a curtain falling over your vision are emergencies that need assessment without delay.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is ectasia never seen after SMILE?
No. Ectasia has also been reported after SMILE. Its likelihood is reduced by preoperative testing and good patient selection, but it cannot be removed entirely.
Which method suits people with thin corneas?
The choice is not made on thickness alone. Corneal shape, the prescription and the amount of remaining tissue are considered together. In some people laser is not recommended, and alternatives such as an implantable lens come into discussion.
What does a biomechanical difference mean for me?
For most people the difference is not noticeable in daily life. What matters is whether your own cornea is sound enough for laser, and only an examination can determine that.
What can I do to protect my cornea after surgery?
Avoid rubbing your eyes, have allergic itching treated and keep your follow-up appointments.
Scientific references
- Guo H, Hosseini-Moghaddam SM, Hodge W. Corneal biomechanical properties after SMILE versus FLEX, LASIK, LASEK, or PRK: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Ophthalmol. 2019. PMID: 31370817
- Ramirez-Miranda A, Mota AD, Rosa GG, et al.. Visual and refractive outcomes after SMILE versus FS-LASIK: a paired-eye study. Cir Cir. 2024. PMID: 39591576
- Moshirfar M, McCaughey MV, Reinstein DZ, et al.. Small-incision lenticule extraction. J Cataract Refract Surg. 2015. PMID: 25804585
- Kim TI, Alió Del Barrio JL, Wilkins M, et al.. Refractive surgery. Lancet. 2019. PMID: 31106754



